Stoltz as Marty McFly
Stoltz was filmed for four weeks, but after seeing a rough cut, Steven Spielberg and the writer/directors decided that Stoltz had played the role too seriously for a comedy, and he was replaced by Michael J. Fox.
Images of the scenes of Stoltz as Marty can be seen on www.bttf.com, where they were posted in 2002. (These can be found by going to www.bttf.com, then clicking upon "photo gallery" and the link to the old site)
Among the scenes that were originally filmed with Stoltz were:
- (with Christopher Lloyd) Doc's first time-travel experiment at the Twin Pines Mall
- (with Crispin Glover, Tom Wilson, and others) Marty's first encounter with George, Biff, and Biff's gang at Lou's Cafe
- (with Glover) The scene where Marty is hit by Sam Baines's car (in commentary with Bob Gale notes that this was the first scene shot when filming began).
- (with Lea Thompson) Marty's first 1955 meeting with Lorraine (a still photo is featured on the DVD bonus feature, "The Making of the Trilogy")
- (with Lloyd) The mind-reading scene
- (with Lloyd) The 1.21 gigawatt conversation between Marty and Doc
- (with Glover) Marty encouraging George to go into Lou's Cafe to ask out Lorraine. Parts of the scene were filmed from inside the cafe, with Lorraine, Betty and Babs in the foreground, and Marty and George seen through the window, a perspective not used when the scene was refilmed.
- (with Glover) Marty describing to George the plan for the fake fight.
- (with Lloyd) Marty and Doc arguing over the "Do Not Open Until 1985" note
In addition, a scene filmed with Stoltz, but not re-filmed with Fox, had Marty being held in detention with Mr. Strickland and escaping by setting off a fire alarm in an elaborate manner. The fourth draft of the screenplay, completed a month before shooting began, provided the script originally written for the scenes filmed with Stoltz. Besides the detention scene, Stoltz's Marty did not wear the down vest that would be mistaken for a life preserver, and drew attention instead for having green tennis shoes.
Other than the Twin Pines Mall closeups, the 1985 scenes had not been filmed. Melora Hardin had been cast as Jennifer after Claudia Wells was filming a television series in 1984. Because Hardin was a few inches taller than Fox, however, she was fired at the same time as Stoltz, without ever having filmed a single scene, although a a publicity photo  showed Stoltz and Hardin together as Marty and Jennifer. Hardin currently plays the role of Jan on the hit TV series, The Office.
Side-by-side comparisons of the Twin Pines and the Lou's Cafe scenes are featured at another site, along with quotes from interviews. The most notable contrast between Stoltz and Fox is their height; at 5'11, Stoltz is six inches taller than 5'5" Fox, and not quite as short in comparison to Christopher Lloyd (6'1") or Thomas F. Wilson (6'3"). When Stoltz's Marty would face off against Biff, Tannen would not seem nearly as intimidating. In a question and answer session at USC, featured on the DVD commentary, Zemeckis and Gale said that J.J. Cohen had been their first choice for Biff, but that Cohen was not large enough in comparison to Stoltz. As such, Tom Wilson became Biff, and Cohen was cast as Skinhead, a member of Biff's gang.
In addition, publicity shots show Stoltz posing with Marc McClure and Wendie Jo Sperber in the photo with Dave and Linda (instead of posing in front of a wishing well, the three stood in front of a wagon wheel, with Linda in the center and Marty on the right).
Much of the original footage, at least for those shots that did not include Marty McFly (or, by extension, Stoltz), was retained for the film. Bob Gale later explained in a commentary track on a DVD release that some dialogue scenes with other actors were from the original shoot. A few long shots with Stoltz as Marty McFly still exist in the film, according to Robert Zemeckis and Gale, and there was at least one "teaser" movie poster released with Eric Stoltz' name and face visible.
One notable scene that was kept in the final film is the one in which Stoltz as Marty drives the DeLorean time machine in the mall parking lot. Since the shots were fairly distant, with the driver's face not particularly visible, the footage was retained.
After the films
Stoltz would later star alongside Lea Thompson in the 1987 John Hughes high school romance film, Some Kind of Wonderful. Shot two years after Back to the Future, the film gives an idea about how Stoltz might have sounded as Marty McFly. Ironically, Stoltz, in the role of "Keith Nelson", had a crush on Thompson's character, "Amanda Jones". Stoltz and Thompson had previously been in the 1984 film, The Wild Life. In 1989, Stoltz was "Martin" in The Fly II, and later as the drug lord, Lance, in Pulp Fiction.
In an interview  with Clint Holmes on moviehole.net, Stoltz was philosophical about the matter, 20 years later. Stoltz agreed with Holmes's suggestion that he would have been "pigeonholed as a teen star" and added, "I think just getting through that difficult period helped me realize how freeing it really was... I actually invested, in myself, in a way that was much healthier for me. If I had become a massive star, I don't know if I wouldn't have gone into therapy." He laughed as he mused, "On the other hand, I would've been exceedingly rich, which would've been wonderful!"
Holmes asked "And then they cast you, when they couldn't get Michael J. Fox, and then they did get him. So, you were just the bait, dude. Bastards!" Stoltz replied, "They were nice people."
On April 19, 2008, Bob Gale participated in a special screening of Back to the Future as part of a benefit for the Make-A-Wish Foundation of Central and North Florida, along with actors Christopher Lloyd, Claudia Wells and Jeffrey Weissman. In a question and answer session after the screening of the , Gale discussed an upcoming release of the trilogy on Blu-Ray high definition disc and was asked about whether any of Stoltz's footage would be seen as one of the bonus features. "No, we get that one a lot," said Gale, "why wasn't it included on the old DVD and why it isn't on the new one. It's because Eric Stoltz is a working actor. We made a mistake putting him in the movie. It's not his fault. But seeing the footage makes him look bad, and it doesn't make us look too good either. We don't want to put something out there that's gonna make someone look bad. We didn't destroy the footage. It's still out there and we know it has historical significance. But maybe in another 20 years we can put that out there, but we don't want to put anything out there that's gonna hurt somebody." 
However, at the DeLorean Car Show 2010, producer Bob Gale confirmed that there will be three short snippets of the legendary Stoltz footage included on the upcoming DVD/BluRay re-issue of the trilogy. (Source: www.bttf.net) The scenes are part of a documentary called "In the Beginning", and do not include sound. The montage is introduced with the familiar scene of Marty slowly appearing to stare at George at Lou's Cafe, but with Stoltz rather than Fox. The next clip is at Doc's house, with Stoltz playing the moment where Marty says "I can't be stuck here! I've got a life in 1985!". In the other clip, Stoltz first arrives in 1955 Courthouse Square, but he's in front of the Ask Mr. Foster travel agency, bewildered by an offer of a vacation in Cuba.
In the Fox series "Fringe", in the alternate reality Eric Stoltz is billed as the star of Back to the Future instead of Michael J. Fox.
- ↑ It can be seen in the photo gallery at bttf.com.
- ↑ http://www.bttf.com/index.php?/weblog/more/bob_gale_hints_at_back_to_the_future_blu_ray_release_at_recent_screening/
- ↑ Id.